This post may contain affiliate links which means I may receive a small commission for purchases made through these links. I promise I will only recommend products that I have personally used! Thank you for supporting our blog so we can continue creating free content each week! Learn more on our Privacy Policy page.
New Year New Cookies
As mentioned in my last blog post – we decided to make one of our goals for 2025 extra sweet! I’ve also written a full blog post dedicated to one of our favorite places at Disney Springs – Gideon’s Bakehouse! In that post, I explained everything you need to know when visiting, including the monthly limited-edition flavors.
So we thought it would be a fun and delicious goal for the new year to make a trip each month to try the unique cookie of the month at Gideon’s Bakehouse, treat ourselves to a day of Disney magic, and use it as a content creation field trip to bring you all more Disney content!
Don’t want to miss a single blog post from us? Sign up for our email list and be notified every time we make a new post!
We made our way over to Disney Springs and were excited to try the January flavor and check the first month of the year off our goal list! Gideon’s Bakehouse at Disney Springs is celebrating its 5th year, and they are celebrating the Year of the Gargoyle!
January’s limited Edition Flavor
THE PEANUT BUTTER CHOCOLATE SWIRL – plus we had to pick up some of our other favorites – Chocolate Chip, Triple Chocolate, and Pistachio Toffee!
“Our devoted protector, the Gargoyle known Agubadiadas, has been on this Earth for centuries. Join us for the Year of the Gargoyle, where we’ll delve into the many marvelous lives he has lived before becoming our beloved mascot. Thank you for embracing our wonderfully weird world and allowing us to share our heartfelt creativity with you.”
They didn’t have a virtual queue, so we waited in line for about 30 minutes, which wasn’t bad in the cooler weather. We bought several cookies, a new candle, and a sticker, and of course, Mark got the irresistible Peanut Butter Cold Brew Coffee. We tucked our treats in the car and spent the rest of the day exploring Disney Springs.
I look forward to featuring many of our favorite places throughout the rest of the year.
Gideon’s Bakehouse Basics
Gideon’s Bakehouse started as a small bakery in Orlando, but it quickly gained a cult following, leading to its much-anticipated location in Disney Springs. Stepping into Gideon’s feels like entering a Victorian-era bookstore with a dash of Tim Burton-esque whimsy. The dim lighting, towering bookshelves, and vintage décor add to the mysterious, slightly eerie vibe that contrasts with the bright and bustling Disney Springs.
Get There Early: The Queue Experience
Pro Tip: Arrive at Disney Springs early, ideally before the shop opens, to minimize your wait time. If you’re there after the opening rush, sign up for the virtual queue if it’s available and use the waiting time to enjoy nearby shops and attractions.
The Menu: Cookies, Cakes, and More
In addition to cookies, Gideon’s also offers decadent slices of cake. The cake flavors rotate, but you can expect options like the indulgent True Red Velvet or the Chocolate Everything Cake. Pair your treat with one of their unique iced coffees, such as Mark’s favorite – the Peanut Butter Cold Brew.
Peanut Butter Cold Brew Pro Tip: Ask for it with NO ice, and you’ll get more of it. Plus, you can save it for the next day and add ice to it at your resort for a morning boost!
The Experience: Beyond the Treats
Part of the charm of Gideon’s is the overall experience. While the wait can be long, the anticipation only adds to the excitement. The gothic-themed interior and attentive staff make the experience feel special, and you’ll likely leave with more treats than you planned because it’s so hard to choose just one!
A Sweet Souvenir
Gideon’s cookies and cakes make excellent souvenirs if you can actually resist eating them immediately. The cookies are individually wrapped and stay fresh for a few days, so they’re perfect for taking home or enjoying later during your Disney trip.
They also sell tumblers, candles that smell just like the store, stickers, and other assorted items seasonally. We can’t wait to see what they have in store for us in February!
Join our Monthly email list and help us grow! We promise you will only receive beautiful photos, updates, and probably a cute cat photo or two in your inbox!
Have you been to the one in East End Market? I wonder if that one is any less crowded…
No we usually don’t shy to far away and use the bus transportations but I have heard it’s less busy on most days!